Home/Rants/🏠 Roofing/Lesson from first roofing gig: Ikarus underlayment at $4500 saved my ass on a shingle job
Lesson from first roofing gig: Ikarus underlayment at $4500 saved my ass on a shingle job
L
LawnLad420
·3mo·29 replies·25 participants
L
LawnLad420⚒️ JourneymanOP3mo
687
First big shingle roof I did, the forecast lied and we got hammered with rain midway through. Switched to Ikarus synthetic underlayment on the fly, cost me an extra $4500 but kept water from sneaking under and ruining the decking. NGL, that stuff breathes better than felt and didn't tear like cheap crap. Wish I'd known sooner, saved a tear-off redo.
L
LadderLad5⚒️ Journeyman3mo
214
Goddamn it, same thing happened on a hip and ridge job last month, felt turned to mush and I had to redo half the damn valley.
R
RoofRascal⚒️ Journeyman3mo
153
Felt is trash in any wet weather. I switched to synthetics years ago, zero callbacks.
P
PaintSplat⭐ Expert3mo
17
Yeah, but synthetics cost more upfront. Worth it?
J
JoistJockey⚒️ Journeyman3mo
125
Hell yes, especially if you're in a rainy area. No more soggy messes.
W
WrenchWarrior⭐ Expert3mo
113
Stick with synthetics like Ikarus for anything over 15 squares. Installs faster too, less wrinkles.
K
KeyKeeper99⚒️ Journeyman3mo
157
Man, I feel that. Rushed a job once without proper underlay and the inspector failed it hard.
W
WrenchWiz⚒️ Journeyman3mo
108
Pro tip: Always double-check the underlay before shingles go on. Overlap by 6 inches minimum.
T
TenYearVet25⚒️ Journeyman3mo
141
This. And use cap nails, not staples. Seen too many blow-offs.
S
ShingleShark14⚒️ Journeyman3mo
27
$4500 extra? Ouch, but better than a $10k redo. Good call.
P
PipeLord420⭐ Expert3mo
155
Exactly. Client never knew, but my sanity did.
T
TenYearVet25⚒️ Journeyman3mo
125
Hit my 10 year mark last week, and yeah, underlayment choice made all the difference on commercial flat roofs too.
P
PipeLord420⭐ Expert3mo
94
For steep pitches, go with a high-temp synthetic. Holds up to the heat without shrinking.
P
PestPatrolPete2⭐ Expert3mo
148
Layer it properly and seal the seams with tape. No leaks, period.
R
RoofRascal⚒️ Journeyman3mo
157
Frustrated as hell with suppliers pushing cheap felt. It's a trap.
P
PaintSplat⭐ Expert3mo
97
Insurance companies hate water damage claims. Synthetics cut that BS way down.
J
JoistJockey⚒️ Journeyman3mo
141
PE firms buying up roofing suppliers, now everything's marked up 20%. Rage.
G
GreenThumbGuru5⚒️ Journeyman3mo
285
Same here, boss cheaped out once and we all paid for it with overtime.
P
PaintSplatter⚒️ Journeyman3mo
252
Echo that. My back still hurts from that one rushed job.
P
PipeDreamer2⭐ Expert3mo
283
Felt the pain on a similar tear-off. Crew was pissed.
B
BrushStrokePro11⚒️ Journeyman3mo
81
Try Grace ice and water shield for valleys. Bombproof and worth every penny.
W
WireWizard12⚒️ Journeyman3mo
97
Don't skimp on underlay, or you'll be back up there in a year. Seen it too often.
C
ComboBreaker⚒️ Journeyman3mo
87
Cat knocked over my coffee mid-install, spilled everywhere. Laugh or cry?
S
ShingleShuffler2⚒️ Journeyman3mo
81
Homeowners demanding 'budget' options then complaining about leaks. Collective eye roll.
C
CastIronCrusher2⚒️ Journeyman3mo
147
Never trust a 3-day forecast on a roof job. Always have backup.
R
RollerRanger2⚒️ Journeyman3mo
176
Yeah, been there. Whole team soaked, but synthetics saved the day.
B
BoxHaulerBob⚒️ Journeyman3mo
23
SharkBite for plumbing tie-ins? Nah, stick to pros, but for roofing, synthetics all the way. Fight me if you disagree.
N
NotAnElectrician17⭐ Expert3mo
148
Relate hard. First year, learned the hard way on underlay. Now it's non-negotiable.
P
PackRatPaul⚒️ Journeyman3mo
165
Watched a video from Roofing Insights on TikTok about this exact issue. Spot on.
F
FurnitureFury⚒️ Journeyman3mo
160
In the Roofing Contractors FB group, everyone swears by synthetics now. No more felt drama.